How would you rate my mix, 1 to 10?

Bernhard
Bernhard — Mastering Engineer

Mix feedback: Why a second ear can give you so much peace of mind.

Louie recently sent me a message. He's a composer and producer who releases as Melouie. I still know his question well from back when I was producing a lot more of my own music:

Melouie
Melouie
morning Bernhard, hope you're doing well. Hey, could you do me a favor and listen to this and tell me what level the mix is at. I can't really judge it myself. Like, on a scale of 1 to 10. Just skip around a bit. If you don't have time, no worries! Thanks
09:14

Hey hey, so I've listened through the track. The mix is really good, nice and clean, nothing hurts to listen to. There are just two small things for my ear:

1. Bass: the bass notes vary quite a bit in loudness. I'm guessing that's a monitoring issue. You could try freezing the bass track down to audio, then adjust with clip gain. In stem mastering I'd handle this with dynamic EQ.

2. The kick feels a bit swallowed by the bass. I'd push the kick a bit more around 60 Hz and use a transient designer to bring out the transient more.

3. You could maybe pull the bass down slightly overall in the parts where the kick isn't playing – but that's more a matter of taste.

Hope that helps.

09:41  ✓✓
Awesome. Thank you so much! Great feedback! 👍
09:43

Pretty much anyone who produces their own music knows this question: Is this working, or have I been sitting on it too long to really hear what's going on?

That's what our Mix Feedback is for: someone listens with fresh ears before the track goes into mastering.

Listening room
The listening room where the track was reviewed.

So I listened to the track start to finish in our mastering room, and the mix sounded really great. Just the bass together with the kick, that was the problem.

Here's what my first tip for Louie could look like in practice:

Bass track before editing, with clearly uneven note-to-note levels in the waveform
Before
The same bass track after freezing and clip gain, with every note at a consistent level
After
Same bassline, same take, just every note as its own clip with the level set by hand.

Freeze the bass with its plugins, bounce it to audio, cut at every note and pull the loud notes down a little with clip gain. Not every note has to be exactly the same level, it's only about catching the outliers. This happens before anything else in the chain, so the compressor doesn't have to iron out what is really a level problem of single notes.

Sure, it takes longer than slapping a plugin on it. But what good does a multiband dynamic EQ do when I can't hear which note is how loud because room modes skew what I hear? And in mastering there's more room left for what mastering is actually about, instead of spending headroom on repairs.

After that, Louie didn't have to guess whether his ear was tricking him. He knew where to start.

Almost anyone who produces or mixes their own music knows this: you spend a long time on your own track, and your ear gets used to things someone from the outside notices right away. A second pair of ears in a good listening room helps, ideally before mastering.

That's why we keep Mix Feedback small and simple: honest suggestions on what you could still achieve in your mix and with which tools. Then mastering can take care of the fine-tuning instead of fixing rough problems.

Thanks to Louie / Melouie (melouie.com) for letting us share this exchange.

Where does your own mix stand?

Honest feedback on your mix before it goes into mastering.

Back to blog